Discussion about this post

User's avatar
The Man Behind the Screen's avatar

Another solid set of definitions and examples here. However, there is one point with which I must take some umbrage:

"Our Common Hero does not wish to become one, thus, he or she outright refuses the Call to Adventure. They absolutely love what they are doing, and have absolutely no desire to leave their beloved pastoral village/neighborhood/cozy high-rise building."

This is not a universal trait to the common hero.

As an example of why this isn't universal, let's look at the hero you use in your cover photo, Luke Skywalker as he is in the original Star Wars. Now, is Luke resistant to leaving Tatooine to go with Old Ben on his search for the princess? Yes he is. But why is he resistant? Is it because he wants to stay on the farm with his aunt and uncle? Is it because he loves the work he does and the planet he calls home?

No. In fact, it's quite the opposite. Luke actively dreams of adventure. He actively dreams of leaving Tatooine to join his friends Biggs and Wedge at the Imperial Academy so they can hone their skills as starfighter pilots together. He also makes it clear that, outside of his family, he has no desire to come back when he does leave. (Recall what he says to Obi-Wan after he finds Owen and Beru dead: "There's nothing here for me now.")

We know Luke values his family because the reason he gives Obi-Wan for why he can't leave is his responsibilities on the moisture farm. However, his responsibilities are not his desires. Luke actively wants to leave. He does not love being a moisture farmer. He does not love Tatooine. He wants adventure. He wants to be a hero. He wants, quite literally, to save the princess. As such, since he is still considered to be one of the poster boys for the common hero while not exhibiting those traits, we can't possibly say that those traits are universal to the common hero.

Expand full comment
The Brothers Krynn's avatar

Never heard of a commoner hero not wanting adventure, I think this article missed the mark there quite a bit. It is still good and gets a lot right, but everymen always crave adventure. It is the most noteworthy thing about them.

Expand full comment
24 more comments...

No posts